|

Manifest Whiskey Project Bourbon Review: An Experiment with Interesting Results

Credit: Anthony Messier

Spice cake, cocoa, and tobacco give this bourbon-and-rye blend its own personality, even if it may leave the purists on both sides undecided.

“Project” is a good word for this whiskey.

Manifest has brought together a high-rye bourbon and a wheated rye, two whiskeys that sound like they should have plenty to say. In my glass, though, their conversation was surprisingly soft. There is spice cake, powdered cocoa, and tobacco, but the rye never gets particularly assertive.

The results of this experiment are interesting, whether it will satisfy someone devoted to traditional bourbon or a more forceful rye is another question.

Manifest Distilling is based in Jacksonville, Florida. Its Whiskey Project series launched in 2016 with a sourced ten-year-old high-rye bourbon. A later release explored whiskey distilled from a neighboring brewery’s stout, so experimentation has been part of the series from early on.

This bottle takes a different approach: blending sourced straight bourbon with Manifest’s own straight rye. Seelbach’s published description of Project No. 4 supports the combination of four-year-old bourbon and younger organic wheated rye, although its current listing is for a different batch.

The bottle reviewed

  • Batch: 4
  • Bottle: 830
  • Proof: 93.4, or 46.7% ABV
  • Whiskey: A blend of straight bourbon and straight rye
  • Bourbon component: Four years old; 75% corn, 21% rye, and 4% malted barley
  • Rye component: Manifest’s two-and-a-half-year-old organic wheated rye; 60% rye and 40% wheat
  • Blending ratio: Not disclosed on the label
  • Sourced bourbon origin: Not disclosed on the label

Those are the individual whiskeys’ mash bills, rather than a combined recipe for the finished blend. Without the blending ratio, we do not know how much influence each component has in the bottle.

Appearance

Score: 3.25 / 5.00

The whiskey shows an appealing amber color in the glass. The bottle has an attractive, modern design, and the distinctive label gives it a personality of its own.

The stopper pairs a black plastic top with a black rubber bottom. It is a straightforward closure rather than a particularly premium finishing touch, but the overall presentation is attractive.

Aroma

Score: 3.75 / 5.00

Spice cake and new leather lead the nose. It is the strongest part of the tasting for me, giving the whiskey an inviting character before the first sip.

The label describes crème brûlée, spice cake, and tobacco. Spice cake is where my experience most clearly overlaps, while new leather makes a stronger impression on me than the sweeter dessert description.

Flavor

Score: 3.50 / 5.00

The mouthfeel is soft, with mild rye character alongside spice cake, powdered cocoa, and tobacco.

Given the combination of a high-rye bourbon and a young rye whiskey, I expected more intensity. Instead, this blend takes a gentler approach. The rye is present, but it does not dominate the sip.

The label suggests chocolate cherry cordial, sweet tea, and baker’s cocoa. Cocoa is the clearest connection to my tasting, coming across more like powdered cocoa than a sweet chocolate confection. Spice cake and tobacco do more of the work here than cherry or sweet tea.

It is an unusual combination, and an enjoyable one, even if the palate does not quite fulfill the promise of the aroma.

Finish

Score: 3.25 / 5.00

The finish stays soft, with rye spice and tobacco lingering for a medium length.

Manifest describes a long, sweet, and spicy finish on the label. Mine was more restrained, both in duration and intensity. There is enough lingering character to complete the sip, but it does not develop into the extended finish that description led me to expect.

Barrel Proof Score

Overall editorial score: 3.50 / 5.00

This experiment produces a pretty good whiskey, with an appealing nose and a soft palate built around spice cake, cocoa, and tobacco. The finish is pleasant enough, although its moderate length and restrained character keep the experience from reaching the same level as the aroma.

The main question is who this blend will satisfy. A rye enthusiast looking for a bold, assertive pour may find it too mild. A bourbon purist may not connect with its particular mix of rye spice, cocoa, and tobacco.

For someone who enjoys exploring the space between those styles, however, there is something interesting here. It has a personality worth discussing, even if it does not land squarely in either camp.

Tasting Notes

Spice cake and new leather on the nose lead into a soft palate of mild rye, powdered cocoa, and tobacco. A medium-length finish leaves rye spice and tobacco behind.

“Project” fits. This tastes like an experiment that gave a pretty good result, with enough individuality to make the tasting worthwhile. I am simply not convinced it will win over the bourbon and rye purists equally.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *