The grain on the nose tells you this is a young bourbon. The first sip tells you what it does well. St. Augustine’s three-year-old Florida Straight Bourbon has a soft mouthfeel and a short finish with no burn. That last part surprised us.

From a Florida Ice Plant to Florida Bourbon
St. Augustine Distillery Co. (DSP-FL-001) makes its bourbon in a restored ice plant that dates to 1917. When the founders were turning the building into a working distillery, they brought in Dave Pickerell, the former master distiller at Maker’s Mark, to consult on the production facility and how it would operate. His work went right down to the equipment. He recommended a gas-fired boiler and designed a process that lets the distillery reuse warm water from cooling one mash to heat the next. Pickerell later helped guide the final blending of the distillery’s first bourbon release, Florida Double Cask.
The Florida Straight Bourbon we tasted was aged three years and bottled at 88 proof. The mash bill is 60% Florida corn, 22% malted barley, and 18% Florida wheat. That’s a substantial share of malted barley, and grain certainly makes itself known when you bring the glass up to your nose.
Appearance | 3.25 out of 5.00
Light golden in the glass. The bottle is well designed, with tall shoulders, a short neck, and a wood-topped stopper with a synthetic plug. The small label leaves room for the best detail. The distillery name is printed directly on the glass, and a black silhouette of the building on the back shows through the front.
Aroma | 3.00 out of 5.00
Grain comes through right away, with a distinct oatmeal note and some dried fruit behind it. The grain is the strongest part of the nose and where the bourbon’s youth is most apparent.
Flavor | 3.00 out of 5.00
Cinnamon and light brown sugar give the sip a simple profile, and the texture is what we kept coming back to. The whiskey feels soft as it moves across the palate. If you’ve ever wondered what reviewers mean by soft mouthfeel, this is as clear an example as we’ve tasted.
Finish | 3.00 out of 5.00
Short and smooth, with tobacco and a little cinnamon. The spice fades quickly, and there’s no alcohol burn after the swallow.
Barrel Proof Score | 3.00 out of 5.00
This lands in our Average to Good range. The flavors are straightforward, and what we enjoyed most was how the soft texture carried into that short finish. We expected more heat from a three-year-old bourbon, and the way it finished was the best surprise of the tasting.
Tasting Notes
If you enjoy a grain-forward bourbon with a touch of sweetness and a finish that gets right to the point, this one fits. We’ll remember it for how it felt on the palate. This is the pour we’d use to show someone what a soft mouthfeel feels like.







