Two years in the barrel set my expectations for Anita’s Choice. Then came the sip. Vanilla led for a moment before cinnamon took over, and by the back of the palate we had one thing in mind: spiced apple butter. That turn was the best part of a young bourbon that scored higher than expected.
Anita’s Choice Six-Grain Bourbon Whiskey · Burnt Church Distillery, Bluffton, South Carolina · 97 proof (48.5% ABV) · 2 years old

Six Grains and a Lowcountry Story
Brothers Billy and Sean Watterson opened Burnt Church Distillery in Bluffton in March 2021. For Anita’s Choice, the distillery looked to the Lowcountry for both the name and the recipe. The bourbon honors Anita Pollitzer, a Charleston-born suffragist and equal rights activist, and its six-grain mash bill includes Carolina Gold rice.
Corn anchors the recipe at 55%, with 13% wheat and 12% barley. Burnt Church’s current product page rounds out the mash bill with 10% Carolina Gold rice, 5% rye and 5% oats. Rice makes up one-tenth of that published recipe, which gives you an idea of how deliberately Burnt Church worked the heirloom grain into this bourbon.
Carolina Gold takes its name from the golden color of the plants when they ripen. Rice became a major export for colonial South Carolina, and the wealth it brought to Lowcountry plantation owners depended on the labor and expertise of enslaved Africans. West African rice growers brought knowledge of wetland cultivation, and enslaved workers built and managed the dikes and waterways that made large-scale production possible. Commercial rice growing eventually faded from South Carolina, and Carolina Gold cultivation saw a revival in the 1980s. Today, finding that grain in a Bluffton bourbon is another way to encounter a crop that helped shape the Lowcountry.
Appearance · 3.50 / 5.00
The bourbon is amber in the glass. The cream-colored label wraps diagonally around the bottle, making it easy to spot on the shelf. The glass stopper with its rubber seal is a nice touch.
Aroma · 3.00 / 5.00
Toasted oak and sweet grain come through first, with spiced fruit rounding out the nose.
Flavor · 3.00 / 5.00
Vanilla opens the sip, and cinnamon and spice come in almost immediately. The back of the palate is where it gets interesting. The fruit and spice come together in a way that reminds me of apple butter with a generous shake of cinnamon.
Finish · 3.00 / 5.00
Medium in length, with oak and cinnamon spice carrying through after the sip.
Barrel Proof Score · 3.00 / 5.00
Average to Good. A 3.00 is comfortably above what I expected from this two-year-old bourbon. The way that sip moves from vanilla to cinnamon to apple butter is where the craftsmanship shows. It still tastes young, and I’d choose a more mature bourbon made with similar care if I had both in front of me.
Tasting Notes
The spiced apple butter is what we will remember about this pour. Six grains make for an interesting recipe, and that’s the moment in the glass that makes me curious about it. Give this whiskey more time in the barrel, and we think later releases can live up to what this one has already earned.







